On March 22, 2011, the U.S. Supreme Court held in Kasten v. Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corp., that retaliation under the Fair Labor Standards Act, can be based on oral complaints, not just written ones. The Court rejected the employer’s argument that oral complaints are too indefinite to provide an employer with fair notice that an employee is engaging in protected activity.
Facts of the Case: The plaintiff employee believed that the location of the defendant employer’s time clock was illegal under the FLSA because it prevented employees from receiving fair compensation for the time they spent changing in and out of work clothes. The employer had an ethics policy that imposed on employees the obligation to report suspected violations of the law and an internal grievance resolution procedure that instructed employees to immediately contact their supervisor with “questions, complaints, and problems.” The employee claimed that he “raised concerns” with his supervisor that the location of the time clocks was “illegal” and that he also advised human resources personnel (a generalist and the HR manager) that the company would “lose in court” if a legal challenge were brought about the time clock location. He also told his lead operator that he was “thinking about starting a lawsuit about the placement of the time clocks.” The employee claimed that his subsequent discharge from employment was because of these complaints. He sued under the FLSA’s anti-retaliation provision and his claims were dismissed on summary judgment. The trial court, affirmed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, concluded that the FLSA, which prohibits retaliation against employees because they “file any complaint” required a written filing with a government agency.
The Rest @ HR That Works
Showing posts with label Litigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Litigation. Show all posts
Thursday, 28 April 2011
Tuesday, 12 April 2011
Saturday, 16 January 2010
What do I do if My Non-Compete Agreement Has Been Broken?
About once a month I get a call from an attorney or a client asking me to get my scorched earth battle gear on because they want to go after an employee/former employee who is competing against them in business after having signed a non-compete agreement.
Sometimes, their stories are compelling and the facts are clear that action must be taken. Sometimes, however, the battle is one of principle that, ultimately, will cost the business owner more in heartache, time away from their own business, and legal warfare fees than the fight is worth.
Whenever the situation is such that the fight is one of pride and principle rather than of solid legal merit, I point my client or colleague to Jay Shepherd’s (Shepherd Law Group) excellent blog post “Eight Ways to Lose a Non-Compete Case.”
His bottom line advice: If you’re truly wearing the white hat (i.e., are the “good guy”), and your agreement is narrowly drafted, and your secrets or customer relationships are indeed in imminent peril, then you’ve got a fighting chance of winning. Otherwise, wave goodbye to the former employee and get back to work.
The Rest by Mary Ann Hisel @ Texas HR Law
The 8 ways to lose a noncompete are:
Lee Royal
Sometimes, their stories are compelling and the facts are clear that action must be taken. Sometimes, however, the battle is one of principle that, ultimately, will cost the business owner more in heartache, time away from their own business, and legal warfare fees than the fight is worth.
Whenever the situation is such that the fight is one of pride and principle rather than of solid legal merit, I point my client or colleague to Jay Shepherd’s (Shepherd Law Group) excellent blog post “Eight Ways to Lose a Non-Compete Case.”
His bottom line advice: If you’re truly wearing the white hat (i.e., are the “good guy”), and your agreement is narrowly drafted, and your secrets or customer relationships are indeed in imminent peril, then you’ve got a fighting chance of winning. Otherwise, wave goodbye to the former employee and get back to work.
The Rest by Mary Ann Hisel @ Texas HR Law
The 8 ways to lose a noncompete are:
- Put your faith in the language of the noncompete agreement.
- Try to enforce against any old employee.
- Make sure the noncompete is broadly drafted.
- Focus [only]on geography, duration, and scope.
- Wait a while to file.
- Ask for the injunction before you've developed enough evidence.
- Don't worry about which state to file in.
- Focus on the law instead of on the story.
Lee Royal
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)